How FinTech's best marketing leaders earn their seat

4 minutes

In FinTech, being commercial doesn’t just mean knowing your numbers. It means operating credibly in an industry where boards closely scrutinise every function against its commercial return. How do you build the case for your next seat while defending and expanding the one you’ve already got? How do you prove that marketing is a commercial driver, not just a brand and campaigns function?

To help marketing leaders navigate their careers in the FinTech sector, Jaemien Serrano from our marketing recruitment team hosted a revenue-focused marketing leadership and AI seminar on Wednesday 11th November. She was joined by:

Together, they discussed:

  • What commercial credibility means for a marketing leader in FinTech
  • Which metrics to own and which relationships to build if you want a genuinely commercial seat
  • How to defend the mandate under pressure and what happens when budgets tighten or ownership changes


Speak the language of the business


Figures on impressions, followers and leads mean nothing to people who care about revenue, so talking in the language of the business is a perennial challenge for marketers. As a Head of Marketing, if you're unable to justify a budget to the CFO or explain outcomes in a way the finance team understands, you'll quickly lose credibility.

One way of demonstrating your commercial impact is to include revenue on your CV. Another approach is to translate softer investments into commercial outcomes when speaking to the business. You can even frame brand health according to things the CFO cares about, such as reduced discounting or increased pricing power.

One of our panellists described starting a new role with the CFO already asking for budget details. Rather than providing an overwhelming, uncoordinated spreadsheet of activity, they presented a clear, high-level strategic story "which is not with 500 disconnected activities, it's with six to nine campaigns that are then going to be driving demand." How you land in a role is also important: "I'm here to try and fix it. Are you going to back me or not?"


Sales ownership

Being directly responsible for a sales target can be a big career accelerator. In the words of one panellist, "you've had that pain of ending the year a hero, and then starting on the first of January as a zero." Looking after sales changes how you judge marketing activity. A particular campaign might look great from an activity point of view, but it might not help anyone close deals.

Of course, not everyone can move into a sales role, so listening to sales calls is the next best way of gaining an insight into how the business works and what buyers care about. One team uses aggregated analysis of sales calls to uncover objection-handling patterns and even misaligned incentives.

Conversation intelligence software is a minimum requirement when joining a new business. Product and marketing teams need to be engaged enough to act on weekly call summaries, so it's useful to ask members of the team how many customer calls they listen to each quarter.


Honesty in measurement

Marketing is hard to measure, so you could be forgiven for being sceptical of anyone claiming to provide a perfect solution. Instead of relying on a single analytics tool, one team combines three different measurement approaches across incrementality tests, a multi-touch attribution model and a marketing mix model. While this is a useful way of providing a high-level picture, being honest enough "not to try and promise something that you can't" is important in gaining the trust of the business.


The brand debate


Activities like brand building, educational content and long-term nurturing are necessary for growth, but it's difficult drawing a direct line between marketing spend and sales. "I know I need to do it, but it's really hard to do it and attribute it well," said one panellist. 


Five pieces of practical advice for protecting your marketing budget:

  1. Show the cost of cutting budget: Sometimes, data is not enough to convince leadership that your marketing's effective, so you need to demonstrate what happens when it disappears. That might mean switching off spend in certain regions to show the impact on the funnel.
  2. Anchor your brand in the customer journey: Build consistent, long-term brand awareness before a customer actually needs your product, so you're already in their mind when a sudden need arises. This is especially important when your services aren't required every day.
  3. Agree leading indicators up front: Brand search volume, web traffic and regional tests won't be reported to the CFO every week, but a plan for tracking them builds their confidence that the investment is heading the right way.
  4. Put a number on it: Put brand in your budget, say what percentage of spend goes on brand and explain why.
  5. Start small: Run a low-risk, tightly budgeted marketing test instead of a wider campaign. Rather than spraying ads at the entire market, target a hyper-specific, high-intent audience. Tighter budgets often produce the most creative work through partnerships.

These tips come with a note of caution. Brand is the easiest budget to cut in tough times, so don't spend on brand before you have product-market fit.


AI is no substitute for judgement


Although they're positive about AI as a productivity tool, the panel are wary of how it's being used. Rebuilding the company's paid channel with Claude in two weeks can uncover mis-targeted spend, but "You can't just run a Claude agent and then just go click, and the whole thing goes away," said one of our panellists.

AI hasn't changed how marketing proves its credibility, but it has increased speed and transparency. Team members can build their own dashboards and ask natural-language questions, such as what happened to pipeline velocity in a particular market in recent weeks. But human oversight and judgement remain essential. Speed counts for nothing if you're building the wrong thing, so teams should validate their ideas with the sales team and customers early on.


Making a senior marketing hire

What are the most important attributes in a senior FinTech marketer? Our panel shared their three main criteria when making a senior marketing hire.


•    Commercial awareness. As a minimum, candidates should know their marketing budget relative to other costs and revenue. Regional leads should also adopt a general manager mindset and build bridges with adjacent teams.


•    Ownership of the numbers. They need to be able to talk through last year's revenue performance, the impact of marketing and why the business succeeded or otherwise. This shows that they're genuinely immersed in the business.


•    Curiosity about the customer. Marketers need to understand who the company serves, what pain it solves, and how to retain and grow customers after the sale.


Assessing a senior marketing role


What should you look for in an employer before accepting a senior FinTech marketing role? Our panel offered eight key tips to help you make the right decision.


•    Ask what success looks like. If the job spec and the interviewer never mention revenue, the role may not be the strategic one you were promised.


•    Pin down the budget and team. If a company isn't prepared to invest in marketing, it doesn't need someone that senior. As well as hiring a marketing leader, they'll also need to hire the infrastructure underneath them.

.

•    Is it a turnaround or a growth story? Many businesses see them as the same thing. Ask what happened to your predecessor and speak to people who have left.


•    Meet people beyond the C-suite. Insist on meeting the head of customer acquisition, the head of account management and the head of enablement, a critical link to the leadership, before accepting.


•    Watch for repositioned roles. A CMO role quietly rebadged as a VP role reporting into the CRO could be a warning sign, although this would provide the clarity of putting marketing on a shared revenue target.


•    Check the founder's view of marketing. Be wary of product-led founders who see sales and marketing as an expense. Do they genuinely want to hire a marketing leader or are they just ticking a box?


•    Look at the business from the outside. If the website is full of vague language or the company talks about a senior leader's personal profile instead of its product, you may be walking into a rebuild. Customers care about the problem the product solves for them, not its technical features or the founders' stories.


•    Get to know the team. After going through many hours of formal interviews, you could benefit from getting to know the team, maybe in a social setting. If you can't imagine working with them, nothing else matters.


Find out how we can help you earn your seat


By speaking the board's language, staying close to sales and customers, being honest about what you can measure and making a clear commercial case for long-term investments, you can earn your seat at the table as a FinTech marketing leader. At the same time, target employers who will give you the scope, budget and openness you need to do the job. If you'd like to join us at our next event, are looking to take the next step in your career or would like to strengthen your team, please contact Jaemien to find out how we can help.